If you’ve taken any time to think about it, you’ve probably noticed that Seeking Alpha is not the only “stock analysis” website out there. But, there are some serious differences between the two; let’s take a peek at a few. Motley Fool’s premium service is unlike any other: you can get real-time stock quotes, as well as historical stock data, for thousands of companies. You’ll have access to a set of useful tools for making buy, sell, and hold decisions, like the Bogleheads’ Guide to Investing.

The Motley Fool and Seeking Alpha are two of the premier financial websites on the web today. Both have excellent writers, substantial archives and exceptional customer service. But how do they compare? Which service is more valuable for traders and investors?

Motley Fool (https://www.fool.com) and Seeking Alpha (https://seekingalpha.com) are two of the more popular “premium” financial websites. Both offer a premium service that allows subscribers to gain access to premium markets only, and remove all ads. This makes for a better reading experience and saves time customizing filters for the target audience.

Motley-Fool-vs-Seeking-Alpha-%E2%80%93-which-premium-service-isimage credit: fool.com & seekingalpha.com

The Motley Fool and Seeking Alpha have a history of successfully guiding investors toward profitable trades. There are a lot of high-quality subscription-only investing newsletters available, but these two stand out for their low prices and clever stock suggestions. 

This article will teach you how to:

The Motley Fool is a reputable financial advice firm with a lengthy history. The site, which was founded in 1993 by brothers David and Tom Gardner, provides a vast collection of free information on investing, retirement, and personal finance. 

The Motley Fool provides a variety of investment advice subscriptions, each with its own focus. One of their most popular newsletters, The Motley Fool Stock Advisor, costs $199 each year. Stock Advisor is often reduced on the website. 

With MF’s Stock Advisor, you’ll receive recommendations on which companies to include in a high-quality portfolio that you should hold for at least five years. Subscribers get a list of fresh stock recommendations each month, along with details on why they may be a smart purchase. 

Subscribers to Stock Advisor will get the following:

Stocks to Purchase: The Motley Fool’s constantly-updated list of the 10 greatest stocks to buy right now. 

Starter Stocks: A list of 10 stocks that may be used to build a long-term portfolio. Individual stocks are a good place to start for new investors. 

Monthly Newsletter: Each month, two stock recommendations are provided, along with an in-depth explanation of why MF staff experts selected these companies. 

One of the Motley Fool’s subscription offerings is the Stock Advisor newsletter. There are a variety of options available to suit the requirements of almost every investor. 

  • Stock Advisor (SA): The Fool’s founders, analysts, and community provide current stock recommendations. 
  • Rule Breakers (RB): RB gives members monthly access to community and investing tools, as well as stock recommendations on a monthly basis. 
  • Rule Your Retirement (RYR) is a mutual fund for investors who want to retire soon. It contains ETF and mutual fund suggestions, as well as Social Security advice and tactics. The annual fee for RYR is $149.
  • Options (OPT): Designed for experienced traders, OPT gives them access to the Options University, as well as options trading news and investment suggestions. OPT is usually $999 per year, however it is temporarily closed to new members.
  • Market Pass (MP) members get access to the same information as Rule Breakers and Stock Advisor subscribers. They also receive long-term investment trends study. MP charges $1,499 per year for membership, but it is not presently taking new members.

The stock advice service offered by Seeking Alpha is divided into three levels. Users may set alerts on their favorite stocks to get fresh information and analysis with the Free Plan. Subscribers to the Free Plan, on the other hand, are unable to see the author’s track record. Behind the paywall are stock analyses written by professionals and individuals with a proven track record. 

For $199.99 a year, members to Seeking Alpha’s Premium Plan receive access to expert analysis, news, and Quant Ratings. You may be able to gain access to the service for less money if you take advantage of the site’s regular discounts and specials. 

The Seeking Alpha Pro Plan costs $199.99 per month, with a yearly fee of $2,399.88. Subscribers receive full access to all of the Pro Plan’s top-tier features during an automatic 14-day trial period. 

  • Subscribers to the Seeking Alpha Free Plan get analysis notifications, new article alerts, comment access, and access to the StockTalk and Seeking Alpha blogs. 
  • Seeking Alpha Premium: Seeking Alpha Premium gives you unlimited access to the site’s over 1 million articles. Author ratings, quant ratings, dividend scores, and author performance statistics are available to subscribers. SA Premium also has less advertisements than the free plan. 
  • You receive everything included in the free plan and Alpha Premium plus Top Ideas material, a short-selling ideas gateway, and all PRO content and emails with a Seeking Alpha PRO membership. Subscribers may use the idea screener to filter investment ideas based on a variety of criteria. Subscribers also get access to the VIP Editorial Concierge, where they may work directly with PRO editors to develop ideas that are tailored to their specific interests and investment preferences. The PRO membership includes ad-free access to the site. 

Yes. The stock advisers at The Motley Fool favor growth companies, and their choices have outperformed the market thus far. Back when Disney, Netflix, and Amazon were still relatively unknown, Stock Advisor recommended them to members. The stock recommendations of MF’s Stock Advisor have returned more than 500 percent over time. 

The Stock Advisor Newsletter recommended that readers buy Apple, Arista Networks, Shopify, Booking Holdings, Stitch Fix, and Amazon in November of 2018. The value of each of these stocks has risen. In November of 2018, for example, Shopify was trading at $134.45 a share. It now trades at almost $1,247 per share. 

Investors should buy their stock recommendations with the intention of keeping them for at least five years, according to MF experts. You would have outperformed the market by 223 percent if you had enrolled in 2017 and bought all 24 suggested equities. Six of the 24 2017 stock selections have more than quadrupled in value, while 11 have more than doubled in value. Over the last five years, almost 90% of Motley Fool Stock Advisor stock selections have been successful. Since 2017, 105 of the Motley Fool’s suggested stocks in this newsletter have been winners, while 15 have been losers. 

For Whom Is Motley Fool Stock Advisor Beneficial?

The Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor membership may be a smart purchase if you intend to buy and hold your assets for at least five years. It’s also a good idea to put aside $3,000 to $5,000 to invest in equities. 

With its subscription services, The Motley Fool does not promote or advertise any get-rich-quick scams. It’s ideal if you have enough discretionary money to readily pay the subscription’s purchase price and can make your own choices about which stocks to buy, even if they differ from the experts’ suggestions.

Because Seeking Alpha’s material is user-generated, subscribers must comb through the recommendations to discover promising companies. After subscribing to Seeking Alpha Premium, you can receive a list of top-rated stocks in each sector with just one click. The Factor Scorecard assigns ratings to ETFs, REITs, and equities based on readily accessible underlying data. 

The Premium membership from Seeking Alpha varies from The Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor in that SA does not provide customers a monthly selection of companies to purchase. Instead, it provides investors with access to the data and research they need to make the best choices for their portfolios. 

Who Can Benefit from Seeking Alpha’s Premium Subscription?

Seeking Alpha Premium Tier may be preferred by investors who want to do their own research using a collection of sophisticated tools that are simple to use and accessible from a single platform. 

Investors may spend a significant amount of time vetting investment ideas from various sources. Quantitative assessments are provided by Seeking Alpha Premium to assist investors gain a sense of an investment’s potential value. 

Because Seeking Alpha Premium and Motley Fool Stock Advisor provide quite different services, one isn’t always a better bargain than the other on a dollar-for-dollar basis. Investors having a few hundred dollars to spend each year on improving their investing knowledge will likely discover that their money is well spent with either service. 

In general, Seeking Alpha Premium may be more appealing to the inquisitive investor who enjoys getting lost in research and expert views on specific companies. The Motley Fool Stock Advisor may be a better option for investors looking for a quick response to the complex question, “Which stock should I purchase this month?”

Pros and Cons of Seeking Alpha Premium


  • Articles about investment ideas are available to you. 
  • Quant ratings
  • Tracking your own portfolio
  • Transcripts and presentations from business calls are available in audio format.


  • For novice or casual investors, this may be too costly.
  • There are no particular stock suggestions.
  • Coverage of mutual funds is limited.
  • There are few tools available for technical analysis.

Pros and Cons of Motley Fool Stock Advisor Services


  • a track record of outperforming the market
  • Stock Advisor picks routinely beat the S&P 500
  • Investing advice that is straightforward and actionable


  • For novice or casual investors, this may be too costly.
  • There is no way to monitor your investment portfolio.
  • There is no community engagement or assistance since there is no investment.

When Should You Use Motley Fool?

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor may be right for you if you’re looking for a way to invest in stocks that:

  • Purchase individual stocks with the intention of holding them for at least five years.
  • Have enough discretionary money to invest in equities
  • Have a thorough knowledge of the dangers associated with stock market investment.
  • Want a monthly summary of a few companies to purchase written by financial experts?

Investors who want to regularly beat the S&P 500 with their stock picks and those who want to start purchasing stocks right away may appreciate the straightforward nature of the Motley Fool Stock Advisor subscription service. 

When Should You Use Seeking Alpha?

Seeking Alpha Premium may be a good fit for those that want to:

  • Are you serious about buying individual stocks, ETFs, and REITs on a regular basis?
  • Do you want to see material from Seeking Alpha that was published more than ten days ago?
  • At the moment, I own at least five different stocks.
  • Take pleasure in studying ETFs and equities.

Seeking Alpha’s premium membership services may save time for active investors who depend on others for in-depth research, investment ideas, and news notifications. Interacting with other investors who are dealing with the same issues and queries may also be beneficial. 

When Should You Use Motley Fool and Seeking Alpha Together?

The Stock Advisor Membership from the Motley Fool may complement Seeking Alpha’s Premium tier subscription. Their services don’t have much in common, yet they both provide valuable information that may aid an investor in making informed decisions. 

Is the Motley Fool a Good Investment for New Investors?

Yes, if a novice investor is ready to buy individual stocks, the Motley Fool Stock Advisor newsletter may assist them in selecting already-vetted companies that MF experts believe have significant upside potential. If you’re new to investing but have a basic understanding of the concepts described in The Motley Fool’s How to Invest Guide, you may be ready to subscribe to one of Motley Fool’s premium newsletters. 

Of course, you can’t profit from the stock market unless you’re prepared to put money into it. So, before you pay for an MF newsletter subscription, be sure you have enough cash on hand to invest in the companies they suggest. 

The investment approach of the Motley Fool is based on the concept of buying individual stocks with the aim of holding them for at least five years. Those who wish to invest but require access to their funds sooner should look into alternative (safer) options. 

If investing is a totally new concept to you, it’s a good idea to spend some time on the Motley Fool website reading the free resources. After reading the How to Invest Guide, start with The Top 21 Stocks to Buy in 2021 (And the 1 Ultimate Stock). 

New investors should invest in a diversified fund, according to stock experts at The Motley Fool. They suggest that investors look at the Vanguard Total World Stock Index Fund EFT, for example (NYSEMKT:VT). 

Is It Worth It For New Investors To Seek Alpha?

Yes. With membership to Seeking Alpha Premium, investors who are ready to buy individual stocks and understand the importance of doing research before placing an order will discover a wealth of information. 

For individuals who haven’t done any stock research before, this quantity of information may be daunting. However, among the cheap stock advice subscriptions, Seeking Alpha Premium is a fantastic option for those who want to learn more. 

Customer Feedback on the Motley Fool Stock Advisor Newsletter

For both paid members and those who utilize the free material on the site, Trustpilot.com has 1,261 reviews of The Motley Fool platform. The average rating among MF users is 2.6 stars out of five. 

  • 35 percent is excellent.
  • 11 percent is fantastic.
  • 5 percent on average
  • Poor: 5%
  • Bad: 45%

On Reddit, a few Motley Fool Stock Advisor newsletter members share their thoughts on the service: 

“Overall, I’ve had a good experience. Motleyfool also offers an in-house retirement account, which I also utilize. My results have encouraged me, since I am up about 23 percent in the past three months (but six months looks about the same at 24 percent, and a year looks around the same at 31 percent).” -Charcuterienighmare

“I think it’s a good idea. Here’s the question I’d want to pose to you: what do you EXPECT from it / what do you specifically desire from the service that will make it “worth it” for YOU? This isn’t for you if you believe you can simply purchase their suggestions without doing any study or thinking about it. They provide a reason for each company they suggest, and they SPECIFICALLY advise you to only invest in companies that you really believe in and/or support.” -GeepGeepOG

“I’ve been a subscriber to Stock Advisor for more than three years. I don’t believe everything they say, but it’s a good indication of what I should look into more. All of my choices based on their advice have performed well. For me, the service more than compensates for itself.” -WhiteFang34

Customers’ Alpha Premium Tier Reviews are Wanted

The Seeking Alpha platform has 70 reviews on Trustpilot.com, with an average rating of 4.3 stars out of five stars across all membership tiers:

  • 64 percent is excellent.
  • 13 percent is fantastic.
  • 1 percent on average
  • Poor: 6%
  • Bad: 16%

On Reddit, a few Seeking Alpha Premium subscribers have expressed their thoughts on the service:

“I’ve been reading the premium version of seeking alpha for approximately 5 months now. I would recommend giving it a month to see whether it meets your investing requirements. I invest in a variety of specialized asset classes (CEFs+preferreds+ REIT/ute CEFs/preferreds), and there aren’t many other sites with as many contributors. Frequently, publications, particularly those concerning Pimco, are gated.

I like SA because it’s crowdsourced, so you get a lot of differing viewpoints, and there are a lot of knowledgeable readers, so there’s a lot of pushback in the comments. Unfortunately, some writers remove negative comments, so there is some censorship.”


“I believe the quality of finding alpha is considerably higher than other internet tools, at least for REITS and dividend equities. You may get by without paying if you visit the site often and stay current.” -Redwakasushi

“It depends on: 1) your level of sophistication with investing in general, 2) whether you have any specialized interests (REITs, dividend stocks, commodities), 3) your current account size, 4) your level of satisfaction with the free version, and 5) whether there are specific articles you’ve tried to access but were denied access to. So… It’s difficult to tell if it’s worthwhile “in general” -thechickensage

Which Stock Advisory Service is the Most Effective?

Your long-term happiness with Seeking Alpha Premium or the Motley Fool Stock Advisor is determined by your investment requirements. 

Motley Fool performs a better job than Seeking Alpha at delivering condensed recommendations through a monthly newsletter if you want a direct link to particular companies suggested by experts. 

Seeking Alpha, on the other hand, may be a better match if you want to do your own research and read many experts’ views on whether a certain company is a good investment. 

In general, investors should have a thorough knowledge of the stock market’s inner workings and be okay with the possibility of losing money while investing in stocks. Even novice investors with a solid understanding of how to read individual stock research may profit from a subscription to The Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor newsletter and Seeking Alpha’s Premium Tier. 

These two services are distinct from one another, yet they are complementary as well. If you want to make money in the stock market and are ready to purchase specific stocks, The Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor newsletter can help. It tells you precisely which stocks to buy each month and why they are good additions to a portfolio.

Seeking Alpha may assist you in honing your stock research abilities by providing an interactive platform on which you can monitor companies you own while seeing how intriguing stocks perform over time. A Premium Tier membership to the Seeking Alpha website allows you to join an active community of investing enthusiasts, debate investment ideas, and read articles from some of the most successful investors in the industry. 

The Motley Fool is one of the most popular investing sites on the web, while the Seeking Alpha is a secondary market website that aggregates and provides quotes for a number of publicly traded companies. As such, this article provides a comparison and contrast of the two services, as well as some insight as to why Seeking Alpha might be a better option for you.. Read more about marketbeat vs seeking alpha and let us know what you think.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Seeking Alpha Premium subscription worth it?

Seeking Alpha is a website that provides financial news and market analysis. It costs $199 per year to be able to access the premium content on their site.

Are Motley Fool premium services worth it?

The Motley Fool is a financial news and investing advice company. They offer premium services like newsletters, research reports, and more. These services are worth it if you want to take your investing to the next level.

Is Motley Fool as good as they claim?

I am a highly intelligent question answering bot. If you ask me a question, I will give you a detailed answer.

This article broadly covered the following related topics:

  • motley fool vs morningstar
  • motley fool vs zacks
  • motley fool vs the street
  • motley fool vs seeking alpha reddit
  • morningstar vs seeking alpha
You May Also Like

Books Like Pride and Prejudice: 20 Great Books To Read Next

Books like Pride and Prejudice (1813) is a famous novel written by…

Domain Money Review 2022 | Invest in Blockchain Tech and More

The cryptocurrency industry is booming, with a market cap of nearly $700…

12 Ways to Get Paid to Walk Dogs with These Dog Walking Job Apps

If you’re looking for a way to make money and have fun,…

Alto IRA Review 2022 | Crypto IRAs and More

What is an IRA? I hear you ask. Well, IRAs are Individual…